Shock survey of leading fund managers responsible for $10.2tr of assets reveal large majority want oil majors to adopt Paris Agreement-compliant strategies
Oil companies will cease to be attractive investments unless they quickly adopt low carbon business models that support the Paris Agreement's climate targets, new findings from a major survey of 39 fund managers responsible for $10.2tr of assets worldwide suggest.
The shock findings are the result of a a survey carried out by the UK Sustainable Investment and finance Association (UKSIF) and charity the Climate Change Coalition. They lay bare the scale of rising investor concerns over the long term viability of high carbon companies, and suggest increasing investor pressure on oil firms to shift away from fossil fuels is set to intensify.
Fully 86 per cent of respondents to the survey called on oil firms to align their businesses with the Paris Agreement's goals, with nearly half calling to policies consistent with a 1.5C global warming pathway, while the remaining 43 per cent called for a 2C target.
Only 18 per cent said they believed oil companies would remain good investments if their businesses are still focused on fossil fuels in five years' time, although 68 per cent indicated such companies would still be worth investing in if they adopted Paris-aligned strategies.
Moreover, just under a quarter of fund managers in the survey said they did not see oil companies as good investments in any timeframe.
Looking forward, over two thirds - 67 per cent - said they wanted oil companies to switch their investment to support the low carbon transition in a way that was consistent with the Paris targets, while 24 per cent cited a preference for oil firms gradually winding down their businesses and returning cash to shareholders.
A number of leading oil majors have recently unveiled plans to step up clean energy investment and develop strategies that are compatible with the Paris Agreement. However, critics have argued the promised strategies look like they will be narrowly focused on emissions from their direct operations and will largely ignore emissions from the fuels oil majors provide, meaning they will still be exposed to 'stranded asset' risks as economies decarbonise.
The new survey follows a report last week by Global Witness which estimated oil and gas companies have altogether earmarked $4.9tr towards new oil and gas fields in the 2020s, but that none of this spending would be compatible with limiting global warming to 1.5C. Such oil and gas exploration would blow a hole in the Paris Agreement targets, while also leaving the industry exposed to stranded assets, the study warned.
Meanwhile, today's survey findings also suggest fund managers are putting investments at risk by failing to align their portfolios with Paris Agreement targets, as only 21 per cent of respondents said they have a policy to do so across all of their funds.
Simon Howard, chief executive of UKSIF, said the writing "is on the wall" for oil firms which do not support global efforts to combat climate change and which fail to rapidly transition their businesses to low carbon.
"The investment community recognises that these will make increasingly risky investments," he said. "But most fund managers need to do much more to protect asset owners, and asset owners more to protect savers, by driving oil companies to change. Both should publicly commit to aligning investment portfolios with the Paris targets and managers should make more fossil free investment products available. They should also coordinate their engagement policies and give them real teeth by setting oil companies deadlines and spelling out the consequences if they fail to take action."
Earlier this month, Bank of England governor Mark Carney alongside governor of the Banque de France, François Villeroy de Galhau, penned a joint open letter warning the global financial sector that meeting the Paris targets required a "massive reallocation of capital" and that companies failing to transition to a low carbon economy "will fail to exist".
Elsewhere, today's survey highlighted rapid changes in investor sentiment over the past year, with only 12 per cent of fund managers indicating they do not have a policy to engage oil companies on climate change, down sharply from 41 per cent in a similar survey last year.
However, while investors are taking a more proactive stance in their efforts to force hiugh carbon companies to mitigate climate risks only 18 per cent have set deadlines for oil companies to take action, and 57 per cent have not yet decided what action to take if oil companies fail to meet their demands, the survey found.
Moreover, the poll suggests many fund managers are struggling to keep up with rapidly growing demand for fossil fuel-free investment strategies. This year 80 per cent said client interest in low carbon investments had grown in the last 12 months, compared to 71 per cent last year and 54 per cent in 2017.
However, respondents reported only a slight growth in the proportion of low carbon funds on offer, according to UKSIF.
Tim Manuel, head of responsible investment at Aon UK, welcomed the survey findings, which he said showed asset owners were increasingly prepared to hold fund managers to account for their action or inaction on climate risk.
"Fossil fuel companies can play an important and positive role in the transition to a low carbon economy, and it is vital that investors use their voice to highlight the importance of this issue, and to support companies' efforts to evolve their business models to meet the challenge," he said. "Asset owners can benefit by setting clear goals and deadlines for how they expect fund managers to engage with companies, and for the circumstances where exclusions should apply."
As investors and fund managers begin to cool towards the oil companies that for so long have been a keystone of their investment strategies, high carbon industries can expect pressure on them to develop credible decarbonisation strategies to ratchet up still further.
Sustained efforts are needed to deploy more renewables and improve electricity access for world's poorest, progress report warns
New plans for a tidal lagoon in Swansea Bay are 'credible and financially viable', according to report for Swansea Council
Charitable foundations and philanthropists should funnel their cash into environmental action, say 11 of the UK's leading scientists
Firm plans to have five new public access stations up and running by the end of the year, in bid to enable long-distance, low emission trucking