• Home
  • News
  • In-depth
  • Opinion
  • Energy
    • Wind
    • Marine
    • Solar
    • Biomass
    • Nuclear
    • CCS
    • Infrastructure
  • Policy
    • Politics
    • Legislation
    • Taxation
  • Management
    • Marketing
    • Risk
    • Skills
    • Incentives
    • Carbon Accounting
  • Technology
    • Waste
    • Recycling
    • R&D
    • Efficiency
    • IT
  • Investment
    • Carbon Trading
    • Offsets
    • Venture Capital
  • Net Zero Now
  • Events & Awards
  • Net Zero Festival
  • Industry Voice
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    • You are currently accessing BusinessGreen via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • Instagram
  • Free Trial
  • Subscribe
  • Events & Awards
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      BusinessGreen Technology & Investment Forum 2021

      Investors and sustainable tech firms are invited to sign up to BusinessGreen's Tech & Investment Forum to explore the investment opportunities offered by the UK's fast expanding green economy.

      • Date: 12 May 2021
      • Online Event
      event logo
      NZF Pathway - Nature 2021

      Net Zero Nature brings together global experts, business leaders, NGO’s and innovators to explore why protecting and restoring nature is fundamental to global economic prosperity, investigate the transformative changes businesses must make now to avoid extinction, and consider best practices and latest developments. Register now to secure your place for a unique day of learning, leadership and practical insight.

      • Date: 27 May 2021
      • Online Event
      event logo
      BusinessGreen Leaders Awards 2021

      From blue chips and start-ups to cutting edge clean tech providers and transforming incumbents, the Awards will honour the very best of UK green business, offering a unique opportunity for the environmental business community to join together to celebrate their many successes and collaborate on the next phase of the net zero transition.

      • Date: 22 Sep 2021
      • Virtual Event, Worldwide
      event logo
      Net Zero Festival 2021

      Net Zero Festival is the world's first business festival dedicated to exploring, advancing, and celebrating the global transition to a net zero emission economy. Join us at BusinessGreen's Net Zero Festival – for leaders who won't wait until 2050 to build a better business, and a better world.

      • Date: 29 Sep 2021
      • Worldwide
      View all events
  • Net Zero Festival
Business Green
Business Green
  • Home
  • News
  • In-depth
  • Opinion
  • Energy
  • Policy
  • Management
  • Technology
  • Investment
  • Net Zero Now
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  • You are currently accessing BusinessGreen via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Hot topics
  • Hydrogen
  • Green jobs & skills
  • Net Zero Nature
  • Technology & Investment Forum
  • Carbon Trading

Kyoto protocol's carbon credit scheme 'increased emissions by 600m tonnes'

  • Arthur Neslen in Brussels, the Guardian
  • 25 August 2015
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

Major UNFCCC carbon trading scheme hit by serious corruption allegations involving organised crime in Russia and Ukraine

A key carbon offsetting scheme was so open to abuse that three quarters of its allowances lacked environmental integrity, a new report says.

UN officials confirm the findings by the Stockholm Environment Institute that around 600 million tonnes of carbon were wrongly emitted as a result, under the UNFCCC's Joint Implementation (JI) scheme.

Related articles

  • Sustainable bond market tipped to hit $1tr in 2021
  • Organic Valley loans dairy farmers funds for renewable energy
  • Heineken toasts new 'carbon neutral' target
  • RE100 initiative hits 300 member milestone

An estimated 80 per cent of JI projects were of low environmental quality, according to the paper which was published today in Nature Climate Change.

"Many of them didn't observe the requirements of JI on 'additionality' as they would probably have happened anyway, and I would even doubt the physical existence of some of these projects," said Vladyslav Zhezherin, one of the report's authors. "I would say that many of them were fake."

A senior UN official speaking on condition of anonymity told the Guardian that the new report was "thoroughly researched and probably correct."

JI had been beset by "significant criminal energy" in Russia and Ukraine, after the EU banned the trading of credits from an industrial gas scam on the Emissions Trading System (ETS) from April 2013, he explained. This led to a flood of what he called "almost completely bogus" credits in 2012.

"It was an outstretched middle finger to the EU saying 'You're shutting out our credits, we're flooding your markets', a mix of retaliation and crime," he said.

Another source with regulatory experience in Ukraine's JI market told the Guardian that, as the 2000s dragged on, JI increasingly came to be seen by market participants there as "a corruption mechanism."

"The approval of projects stopped depending on their quality but rather on connections and side payments," he said. To gain official approval for registration under the JI scheme, Ukrainian market participants often had to transfer ERUs to a limited number of intermediary companies in Switzerland, the source alleged.

Russia and Ukraine were the two biggest beneficiaries of the JI system, which allowed them to trade emissions reductions units (ERUs) 'proving' that carbon cuts had been made, for assigned amount units (AAUs) from rich world polluters, in the exotic lexicon of carbon trading.

But under the scheme's 'Track 1' - which covered around 97 per cent of projects - states only needed to verify reductions between themselves, without any UNFCCC oversight.

The eastern countries had been over-supplied with credits after the fall of the Soviet Union - but before its subsequent industrial collapse. They were also smarting at the withdrawal from the Kyoto protocol of their presumed main buyer, the USA.

A decision to flood the EU's carbon market with dud credits "was partly because of hurt feelings from having had no proper compensation," the UN source said.

He added: "This is what happens if you give free resources, or install a subsidy-like mechanism without proper oversight in failing states, or countries with significant corrupt structures."

The issue may well be discussed at climate talks in Paris, where the EU is pushing for oversight of future market-based mechanisms to be take out of the UNFCCC's hands.

The UN body is believed to prefer a reformed version of the scheme's ‘Track 2', for which it has oversight.

Anja Kollmuss, another of the study's authors, said the implications of the story for the EU emissions trading system (ETS) would be profound. "Almost two-thirds of JI credits were used in the ETS, so the poor overall quality of JI projects may have undermined the EU's emission reduction target by some 400 million tonnes of CO2, about a third of the reductions required by the ETS from 2013 to 2020," she said.

More than a quarter of JI carbon credits went to projects to staunch the spontaneous ignition of coal piles, mostly in Ukraine. The country's estimate that such waste piles produced roughly 30 per cent of its coal was "highly unrealistic" and probably led to substantial over-crediting, the report says.

The report found that only one of the six major project types in the JI system reduced emissions by more than would have happened anyway. This covered N20 abatement from nitric acid production, and was also the only project-type correctly supplied with ERUs.

JI is one of the three carbon offsetting schemes accredited by the Kyoto protocol - along with emissions trading and the clean development mechanism. It allowed some 872 million ERUs to be issued by ex-Soviet Union and Warsaw Pact countries, accounting for around a third of UN-accredited emissions allowances.

This article first appeared at the Guardian

BusinessGreen is part of the Guardian Environment Network

Further reading

Brazil gives green light to over 600MW of clean energy projects
  • Wind
  • 25 August 2015
Investment consultants and pension funds accused of holding back green investment
  • Risk
  • 25 August 2015
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Carbon Trading
  • Policy
  • Offsets
  • Kyoto
  • United Nations
  • Paris Summit

More on Carbon Trading

    • Policy
Green remedy: How a net zero global healthcare sector could help cure planetary ills
    • Policy
    • 16 April 2021
Reducing air travel can significantly reduce lifestyle carbon footprints
    • Policy
Citizen power or climate chaos: How can policymakers and businesses encourage low carbon behaviours?
    • Policy
    • 15 April 2021
Modular, low carbon homes being developed in Kent | Credit: Public Sector plc
    • Buildings
Future Buildings Standard: Building professionals and green NGOs slam 'significant shortcomings'
    • Buildings
    • 14 April 2021
    • Energy
Why was the Green Homes Grant scheme scrapped so quickly?
    • Energy
    • 14 April 2021
The climate impact of beef and dairy farming has come in for increasing scrutiny in recent years
    • Offsets
CowCredits: Mootral aims to cut cattle burps through carbon offset offer
    • Offsets
    • 14 April 2021
    • Policy
Top US business leaders urge Biden to deliver 'bold' 2030 emissions goal
    • Policy
    • 13 April 2021
The Belgium National Bank building in Brussels | Credit: Banque nationale de Belgique
    • Policy
ClientEarth sues Belgian National Bank over high-carbon corporate lending policies
    • Policy
    • 13 April 2021
    • Policy
People want a carrot (not stick) approach to low carbon food
    • Policy
    • 13 April 2021

More news

Sustainable bond market tipped to hit $1tr in 2021
  • Investment
Sustainable bond market tipped to hit $1tr in 2021

SEB revises its predictions for sustainable bond market upwards, after stellar results in first quarter of the year

  • 16 April 2021
Organic Valley loans dairy farmers funds for renewable energy
  • Supply chain
Organic Valley loans dairy farmers funds for renewable energy

How Organic Valley is leading a growing trend designed to tackle Scope 3 emissions

  • 16 April 2021
Heineken toasts new 'carbon neutral' target
  • Management
Heineken toasts new 'carbon neutral' target

Brewing giant pledges to deliver carbon neutral production by 2030 and full value chain by 2040

  • 16 April 2021
Green remedy: How a net zero global healthcare sector could help cure planetary ills
  • Policy
Green remedy: How a net zero global healthcare sector could help cure planetary ills

Health systems will bear the brunt of the climate-related health emergencies, so bold action needs to be taken to reduce the sector's ever-growing emissions, a new report argues

  • 16 April 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

'A truly momentous occasion for glass': Diageo produces glass whisky bottles in waste-powered furnaces
'A truly momentous occasion for glass': Diageo produces glass whisky bottles in waste-powered furnaces
'Tipping point': Study reveals electric trucks are 'very close' to challenging diesel vehicles
'Tipping point': Study reveals electric trucks are 'very close' to challenging diesel vehicles
Will the covid crisis herald the end for the age of the business flight?
Will the covid crisis herald the end for the age of the business flight?
Facebook posts 'net zero' operational emissions status update
Facebook posts 'net zero' operational emissions status update
'Zap Flash': Good Energy to offer electric vehicle drivers free power
'Zap Flash': Good Energy to offer electric vehicle drivers free power
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Incisive Footer Logo

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading