Members of civil society during the Peoples Plenary at COP31 / Credit: UN Climate Change - Kiara Worth
Increasingly the Action Agenda at the annual COP Summits is where the action is - but the fraught negotiations help drive that real world progress
Frustration, and tiredness, are building in Antalya. Questions about how things are going result in shrugged shoulders, shaken heads, weary laughter.
Fears are growing the innovative - read high risk - decision to publish a lengthy draft cover text at the start of the week may have backfired. Typically, when a COP enters its final scheduled day, the negotiations narrow down to a handful of contentious issues and a landing zone for the final accord starts to take shape. But with the initial draft text from earlier this week having adopted an 'all the issues, all the time' strategy, governments now appear to be at loggerheads on seven or eight substantive issues.
Fierce disagreements are raging over the proposed electrification target, the transition away from fossil fuels, the 'overshoot' beyond 1.5C of warming, the next IPCC report, climate finance pledges, climate adaptation funding, just transition mechanisms, and plenty more besides. There are incompatible red lines as far as the eye can see.
The latest slimmed down text published yesterday afternoon seeks to broker a compromise on these issues - and excise the vexed references to the transition away from fossil fuels altogether. Its success or failure will now be determined over the next 24 hours or so, as negotiations continue round the clock. But the initial prospects do not look great, with Panama breaking cover to publicly signal it will block what it regards as an outrageously weak agreement.
The deadlock between the various parties means that when - should that be if? - a deal is reached it will inevitably be characterised as a toothless compromise that falls far short of what is required. There will be justified anger the climate finance can has been kicked further down the road and the likely refusal to even name fossil fuels as the primary cause of the climate crisis. Another round of discussion over whether to reform a COP process that is clearly unfit for purpose, or perhaps even ditch it altogether, will follow.
But, as always, such a debate would risk missing the bigger picture.
COPs are about diplomacy and geopolitics, which means they always struggle when multilateralism is under intense pressure from big power muscle-flexing. As one journalist noted today, this summit is taking place at precisely the same time as the leaders of the US, Russia, and China are meeting to agree to boost oil production.
But COPs are also about market signals - the direction they send to the businesses and investors tasked with delivering practical climate action on the ground. Consequently, even COPs that make limited progress on technical matters or are condemned as a 'failure' by campaigners can still have significant positive impacts.
This is particularly apparent through the talks' Action Agenda, which over the past fortnight has been jam-packed with ambitious new commitments, pioneering clean tech and nature projects, and multi-billion dollar investments. Yesterday's Electrification Delivery Package provides a case in point, collating new and updated electrification plans from 150 countries plus the EU, 37 cities, and over 260 businesses, with more than $4tr a year in collective annual revenues. All around the world many billions of dollars are being invested in clean energy, grids, electric vehicles, and industrial electrification. This is economy-shaping stuff and for all its flaws the annual COP caravan helps make it more visible and highlights the immense environmental, economic, and security benefits it brings. It is a key component in the critical global push to make the clean energy transition a self-fulfilling prophecy.
This progress is mirrored to varying degrees by myriad announcements and commitments on food and sustainable agriculture, the circular economy, oceans, shipping, forests, climate adaptation, fossil fuel transition roadmaps, carbon removals, climate finance, and much more besides. It is easy to gloss over this avalanche of announcements and it is true they vary considerably in scale and credibility. But they are often tied to real investments and actual projects that are driving change on the ground. They constitute action and promoting them helps breed more action.
This Action Agenda is also in a symbiotic relationship with the political and technical negotiations. Ever since the Paris Agreement, and arguably long before that, it has been possible to translate the diplomatic and legalistic language contained in climate agreements into signals that shape national policies, inform corporate strategies, and unlock clean tech investments.
For all its flaws, COP31 is no different. The likelihood of a historic recognition that an overshoot beyond 1.5C of warming is happening will help make it clear decarbonisation efforts must accelerate, climate adaptation spending must increase, and a multi-billion dollar carbon removals industry has to be built. More narrowly, a global electrification target would provide a further signal to what the COP31 President of Negotiations Chris Bowen keeps calling the "boardrooms and living rooms of the world" that the global clean tech boom is now irreversible.
When companies - be they multinational giants or exciting start ups - go to investors and ask for capital to deploy solar panels, upgrade grids, purchase EVs, install heat pumps, or develop new carbon removal technologies, these signals make it more likely those investors will say 'yes'.
It would be better - much better - if the final agreement could find a way to send even stronger signals. To reassert the fact that a transition away from fossil fuels is essential. To confirm promised flows of climate finance will be honoured and provide a credible plan for doing so. To offer a more detailed explanation for how 'overshoot' can be limited and reversed. The COP process is failing on its own terms, as evidenced by still rising global emissions and ever escalating climate impacts. Everyone needs to try harder still and those blocking more ambitious action should sit with their consciences.
But there is still value in the pursuit of the most ambitious agreement that consensus will allow through the COP process and the repeated reassertion of the multilateral vision embedded in the Paris Agreement. Everyone in the corridors and negotiating rooms at COP31 looks and feels exhausted, but as the talks approach their end game they can comfort themselves with the fact they are doing important work. When the Paris Agreement was signed the world was on track for around 4C of warming this century; we are now on a path for around 2.7C of warming - the forecasts are still catastrophically high and the risk of irreversible tipping points is real, but progress is being made. The connection can seem frayed at times, but climate negotiations can and do lead to climate action, and that action is starting to make a difference.
A version of this article first appeared as part of BusinessGreen's Overnight Briefing newsletter, which is available to all BusinessGreen Intelligence subscribers.




