• Home
  • News
  • In-depth
  • Opinion
  • Energy
    • Wind
    • Marine
    • Solar
    • Biomass
    • Nuclear
    • CCS
    • Infrastructure
  • Policy
    • Politics
    • Legislation
    • Taxation
  • Management
    • Marketing
    • Risk
    • Skills
    • Incentives
    • Carbon Accounting
  • Technology
    • Waste
    • Recycling
    • R&D
    • Efficiency
    • IT
  • Investment
    • Carbon Trading
    • Offsets
    • Venture Capital
  • Net Zero Now
  • Events & Awards
  • SDG Hub
  • Industry Voice
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    • You are currently accessing BusinessGreen via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • Instagram
  • Free Trial
  • Subscribe
  • Events & Awards
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      NZF Pathway - Finance

      This exclusive half day online event will investigate how all businesses can support and accelerate the transition to low and net zero carbon buildings, while maximising the financial and productivity opportunities that will result.

      • Date: 16 Mar 2021
      • Online Event
      event logo
      Net Zero Festival 2021

      Net Zero Festival is the world's first business festival dedicated to exploring, advancing, and celebrating the global transition to a net zero emission economy. Join us at BusinessGreen's Net Zero Festival – for leaders who won't wait until 2050 to build a better business, and a better world.

      • Date: 27 Sep 2021
      • Worldwide
      View all events
  • SDG Hub
Business Green
Business Green
  • Home
  • News
  • In-depth
  • Opinion
  • Energy
  • Policy
  • Management
  • Technology
  • Investment
  • Net Zero Now
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  • You are currently accessing BusinessGreen via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Hot topics
  • Green recovery
  • Net Zero Now
  • Net Zero Leadership
  • Net Zero Finance
Blog post ribbon image
  • Climate change

Why we all need Marvel's climate courage

Why we all need Marvel's climate courage
  • James Murray
  • James Murray
  • @James_BG
  • 05 March 2018
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

Dr Kate Marvel's essay, 'We Need Courage, Not Hope, to Face Climate Change', may just provide the framing the climate movement needs

I've now read it three times, and the first impression stands. Dr Kate Marvel's essay, We Need Courage, Not Hope, to Face Climate Change, is one of the most powerful pieces you will read on climate change. It is urgent, vital, and beautiful. A review won't do it justice, you really should just read it.

It only takes five minutes, but packed into its 1,110 words are one of the most strikingly memorable explanations of the basic, unrelenting physics of our atmosphere; a hammer blow, emotional acknowledgement of the threat climate change poses to all we hold dear; and, just perhaps, the glimmer of a way forward. If you work in sustainability, have an interest in science communications, or just care about the future, you really must just read it.

Related articles

  • The Boy Who Cried Wolf: Redux
  • No hugging, no learning
  • 2020: A year of crisis, crossroads, and alternative histories
  • The Energy White Paper and the nuclear stand-off

And when you have read it - when you have soaked up Marvel's descriptions of human life "incandescent with the power of a hundred-watt bulb" and "dancing" carbon dioxide, her fear of how "we burn coal and oil and gas, heedless of the consequences", her admission "the world we once knew is never coming back", that we are "sending our children to live on an unfamiliar planet"- it is worth thinking about.

Because in the midst of an undeniably bleak essay, Marvel may just have hit on a means of resolving the dialectical tension between climate optimism and climate pessimism, and in the process identified a concept that could prove immensely useful to politicians, business leaders, and campaigners alike: climate courage.

I've written plenty in the past about the ways in which working on environmental issues is a constant battle to keep the joy and the fear in some sort of balance, and how a blunt climate optimism is tempting, but also problematic and risky. It is understandable that when addressing climate change politicians, CEOs, and campaigners all default to a fuzzy optimism, a sense that we can 'solve' or 'beat' or 'defeat' climate change which singularly fails to acknowledge how these verbs are pretty meaningless in the face of an existential, planetary scale physical phenomenon.

There are still good reasons to embrace this narrative, to relentlessly highlight the technologies and infrastructure and business models that could decarbonise the global economy and drive up living standards - I do it every day. But there is a constant risk this climate optimism, being built on the shakiest of foundations, becomes unbalanced, tips over into a naïve hope technology will save us - a hope that inevitable downplays the epic scale of the risks we face.

This perennial debate is getting an airing currently thanks to Steven Pinker's new book on the Enlightenment and accompanying essay on Enlightenment Environmentalism. Pinker offers a more nuanced take on climate optimism than most, citing the work of the economist Paul Romer and the crucial difference between complacent and conditional optimism. Complacent optimism is "the feeling of a child waiting for presents on Christmas morning", Pinker writes, while conditional optimism is "the feeling of a child who wants a treehouse and realizes that if he gets some wood and nails and persuades other kids to help him, he can build one". "We cannot be complacently optimistic about climate change, but we can be conditionally optimistic," he concludes. "We have some practicable ways to prevent the harms and we have the means to learn more. Problems are solvable."

This conditional optimism is entirely justified, but, for me, the way Pinker communicates on climate change, in writing and through interviews, fails to adequately express quite how conditional our optimism should be.

He may acknowledge climate change is the biggest challenge to his otherwise well-founded confidence in human progress, but he still fails to sound the alarm bell as loudly as is required in the face of a threat that could implode his entire hypothesis. His conditional optimism fails to adequately engage with the fact we have been collectively striving to create the conditions for greater optimism on climate change for over three decades, and yet global emissions are still not falling. It also fails to adequately highlight how the scale, reach, and pace of the low carbon industrial revolution that is now required is without historic precedent. All of which helps to explain why Pinker's optimism is so shamelessly purloined by a climate denialist tendency that does not fully understand it, just as it explains how the wider climate optimism narrative can inadvertently fuel a sense of complacency.

As Marvel puts it: "I have infinite, gullible faith in the goodness of the individual. But I have none whatsoever in the collective. How else can it be that the sum total of so many tiny acts of kindness is a world incapable of stopping something so eminently stoppable? … Change is already underway; individual worries and sacrifices have not slowed it."

The question then is how to respond when faced with an outlook so bleak, and it is here Marvel offers a profound break with the stale climate hope v despair debate. What we need, she argues, is courage. Her conclusion is worth quoting at length:

"I have no hope that these changes can be reversed. We are inevitably sending our children to live on an unfamiliar planet. But the opposite of hope is not despair. It is grief. Even while resolving to limit the damage, we can mourn. And here, the sheer scale of the problem provides a perverse comfort: we are in this together. The swiftness of the change, its scale and inevitability, binds us into one, broken hearts trapped together under a warming atmosphere.

"We need courage, not hope. Grief, after all, is the cost of being alive. We are all fated to live lives shot through with sadness, and are not worth less for it. Courage is the resolve to do well without the assurance of a happy ending. Little molecules, random in their movement, add together to a coherent whole. Little lives do not. But here we are, together on a planet radiating ever more into space where there is no darkness, only light we cannot see."

If climate optimism risks complacency and climate pessimism risks nihilistic inaction, what of climate courage?

Here is a narrative that resonates, one that acknowledges the full scale of the challenge and the necessity of facing it with all the nerve we can muster.

It also holds an intense psychological appeal. Who doesn't like the idea of being hailed for their courage? Who wants to be accused of cowardice in the face of crisis?

Here is a term that can galvanise climate action without simultaneously undermining it. A term that hints at the martial metaphor provided by the 'decarbonisation is like a war effort' narrative, but also extends to the small acts of courage we can all embrace in our own lives in the cause of the environment.

Most of all though, climate courage has the benefit of being true.

A few years back Apple's marketing chief Phil Schiller prompted some well-deserved mockery for explaining the reason the company was ditching the standard headphones port on its phones - a decision that resulted in plenty of resource inefficiency and e-waste, for what it is worth - with one ill-judged word: "courage". It does not take "courage" to change headphones, but to fundamentally and rapidly transform a business in response to climate change, in the face of fierce opposition and with no guarantee of success? That takes a little courage. To push through policies which may prove unpopular with the media and public, which could cost you your political career, but which are essential for a country's long term prosperity and security? That takes a little courage. To venture out into ever more intense storms or floods to help those in need? That takes more than a little courage.

Marvel's essay reminded me of another exceptional piece of writing on climate optimism by the US journalist David Roberts, who back in 2013 asked "is there any hope? Or are we just f*cked?" His conclusion was that climate action remains imperative for two undeniable reasons. Firstly, complex systems are "nonlinear" and can deliver unanticipated phase shifts - in other words, a miracle may might just turn up if we strive for it. And secondly, what else are we going to do? As Roberts concluded: "Remember, there is no 'too late' here, no 'game over' - it will be a tragedy to shoot past two degrees to three, but four is worse than three, and five is worse than four. Being unprepared for any of those will be much worse than being prepared. The future always forks; there are always better and worse paths ahead. There's always a difference to be made".

Making that difference depends not on reductive climate optimism or despairing climate pessimism. It depends on courage. It depends on "the resolve to do well without the assurance of a happy ending". Has there ever been a better description of the global project to tackle climate change than Marvel's beautiful turn of phrase? Again, you really must read it, and then muster what climate courage you can.

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Climate change
  • Risk
  • Marketing
  • Climate communications
  • In-depth

More on Climate change

Extreme weather events and other climate-related threats remain the biggest risks facing the global economy, according to the latest Global Risk Report
    • Policy
Covid and climate: Annual Davos report raises alarm over escalating, intertwined risks facing the global economy
    • Policy
    • 20 January 2021
Controversy continues to exist over the size of the emissions reductions carbon dioxide removal processes will be able to deliver
    • CCS
Necessity or distraction? How carbon capture and negative emissions debates are starting to heat up
    • CCS
    • 19 January 2021
Meathane leakage can occur during production, transportation and distribution of oil and gas
    • Energy
Peak methane? IEA urges oil and gas sector to plug methane leakage
    • Energy
    • 18 January 2021
Boris Johnson at the launch of the COP26 Summit at the Science Museum in early 2020
    • Policy
Poll: Two-thirds of adults believe UK government should do more to combat climate change
    • Policy
    • 17 January 2021
Adapting to increasingly severe climate impacts has fallen is not receiving enough attention from governments, according to UNEP | Credit: South Agency
    • Climate change
Climate adaptation: Could nature based solutions help bridge the gap?
    • Climate change
    • 14 January 2021
BlackRock's coal exclusion policy applies to miners that generate 25% of revenue from the fossil fuel
    • Investment
'Climate pariah': Campaigners urge Blackrock to strengthen coal exclusion policy after counting $85bn of coal investments
    • Investment
    • 13 January 2021
Credit: Rich Carey
    • Investment
Can banks become the solution to - rather than a driver of - global deforestation?
    • Investment
    • 13 January 2021
    • Politics
Honouring the Paris Agreement Goals: A way forward
    • Politics
    • 12 January 2021

More news

Electric vehicle sales accelerated through 2020 - but cost remains a roadblock, RAC analysis finds
  • Transport
Electric vehicle sales accelerated through 2020 - but cost remains a roadblock, RAC analysis finds

EV uptake continues to accelerate but price, access to infrastructure and driving range continue to deter many drivers, new analysis from RAC has found

  • 21 January 2021
Data should be a net zero priority
  • Technology
Data should be a net zero priority

Building a reliable and comprehensive data infrastructure is crucial for net zero decision-making and accountability, writes TechUK's Susanne Baker

  • 21 January 2021
New National Circular Economy Hub planned for University of Exeter
  • Recycling
New National Circular Economy Hub planned for University of Exeter

National Interdisciplinary Circular Economy Hub backed by new funding from UK Research and Innovation

  • 21 January 2021
Green beans: Heinz heats up sustainable packaging push
  • Waste
Green beans: Heinz heats up sustainable packaging push

Food giant announces roll out of new recyclable paperboard multipack sleeves as part of £25m investment in sustainable packaging innovations

  • 21 January 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

Mars and DHL plot £350m UK logistics hubs to slash one million road miles
Mars and DHL plot £350m UK logistics hubs to slash one million road miles
Octopus Energy launches 'world's first' tariff to get cheaper when its windy
Octopus Energy launches 'world's first' tariff to get cheaper when its windy
UK housebuilders to face 'zero carbon ready' standard from 2025
UK housebuilders to face 'zero carbon ready' standard from 2025
Vauxhall faces mass action lawsuit over alleged emissions test 'cheating'
Vauxhall faces mass action lawsuit over alleged emissions test 'cheating'
Scaling up sustainable finance: How can investors accelerate the net zero transition?
Scaling up sustainable finance: How can investors accelerate the net zero transition?
  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Incisive Footer Logo

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading