Delegates participate in contact groups throughout the day at COP31 / Credit: UN Climate Change - Kiara Worth
An agreement on the urgent need to limit 'overshoot' beyond 1.5C of warming looks within reach - and whether they spell it out or not, governments are starting to recognise action on carbon removals will become essential
The mood in the halls at the COP31 Climate Summit is curiously downbeat. The sun is shining, the Turkish coffee is good and not exorbitantly over-priced, and the bus chaos of the first week appears to have been resolved. But seasoned COP watchers are worried. Far from providing the talks with renewed momentum going into the second week, the Australian Presidency's decision on Monday publish a lengthy draft cover text has only served to highlight the large number of areas where negotiating blocs remain implacably opposed. With three scheduled days to go, it is difficult to identify the 'landing zone' for an ambitious agreement.
In publicly floating proposals for new fossil fuel transition roadmaps, clean electrification targets, and more detailed climate finance commitments that breach the long-standing red lines of many of the key players, the Presidency has made it all but inevitable any final agreement will be characterised as a weak and watered down compromise beholden to petrostate interests.
Some insiders are starting work on the post mortem already, asking if a cover text was even needed at this stage in the COP cycle and whether more could have been done to manage expectations? Should the widely-held perception an electrification target was a 'slam dunk' have been allowed to develop? Should the draft text have come later in the process and offered a narrower focus on the areas where compromise was plausible?
The harsh reality is COP Summits rarely make significant leaps forward, and when they do it is usually because the superpowers of the US and China want them to - and are willing to bang some diplomatic heads together in pursuit of their goals. Without such geopolitical alignment, what leverage can be brought to bear to nudge Saudi Arabia, Russia, and other petrostates towards multilateral measures explicitly design to curb demand for their fossil fuels?
Meanwhile, everyone else is left trying to work out how to explain to the public that 100,000 people were brought together on the Mediterranean coast to deliver a climate agreement that looks weaker than the one reached three years ago. How is it that certain governments were willing to back a transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems at the Dubai Summit in 2023, only for them to spend the next few years blocking any attempt to explain how that process might be delivered?
And yet, there are important ways in which COP31 might yet deliver significant, perhaps even historic, progress.
The draft text repeatedly acknowledges the world is all but certain to breach the Paris Agreement's 1.5C warming threshold and references the need to minimise the 'overshoot' before bringing temperatures back down towards the original goal. Negotiations will continue over the precise wording, with many delegations keen to emphasise the primary response to any overshoot must be a redoubling of efforts to decarbonise, a renewed push to tackle methane emissions, enhanced protection and restoration of natural carbon sinks, and increased investment in climate adaptation. But whether it is referenced implicitly or explicitly any commitment to tackle the 1.5C 'overshoot' suggests a global carbon removals industry will now have to be built at pace and scale.
If the main purpose of COP Summits - some would say the only purpose - is to send market and investment signals to the real economy, then an international recognition the 1.5C goal is in the rear view mirror and the only way to get back there is through a combination of rapid decarbonisation and natural and/or engineered carbon removals is a valuable signal. It would no doubt prove hugely controversial with some campaign groups that remain convinced attempts to draw down greenhouse gases from the atmosphere are a dangerous distraction, especially when direct emissions are still yet to fall. But such a text would underscore how the cost and feasibility challenges associated with the fledgling carbon removals sector simply have to be overcome.
This could become the carbon removals COP.
Moreover, an agreement on tackling the 1.5C overshoot may help unlock progress in other areas. If overshoot is to be limited then electrification, whether initially clean or not, is a much cheaper way of slowing temperature increases than building out ever higher levels of carbon removal capacity. If overshoot is inevitable, more funding for adaptation becomes a necessity. If we are in the process of breaching the1.5C threshold, it would be good to have an independent assessment of the latest climate science sooner rather than later. And if we are to stop temperatures spiralling out of control, how can that be done without a strategy for transitioning away from fossil fuels?
It is vanishingly unlikely the petrostates and their allies will move their red lines in any meaningful way and consequently the coming days are set to defined by yet another pitched battle over the future of fossil fuels and how best to accelerate and finance global climate action. But there is value in having that fight and staging it in public. Not least because as temperatures move beyond 1.5C of warming it sends a signal that for all the deep disagreements and the entirely justified anger at the failure to deliver flows of climate finance at the scale required, the vast majority of nations recognise what is happening to the climate and are still working to deliver the clean technologies, climate resilience, and carbon removals that might yet keep 1.5C alive.
A version of this article first appeared as part of BusinessGreen's Overnight Briefing newsletter, which is available to all BusinessGreen Intelligence subscribers.




