28 Jun 2010
The Carbon Trust looks set to be scrapped as the government seeks to identify £2bn worth of savings to fund the formation of its proposed Green Investment Bank.
According to reports in The Sunday Times yesterday, the flagship environmental business body is one of dozens of quangos being lined up for the axe as part of the government's cost-saving plans.
The plans will be set out in a report later this week from former chairman of Merrill Lynch in Europe Bob Wigley, who was commissioned by the Conservative energy and climate change minister, Greg Barker, to identify how best to finance and operate the coalition government's planned Green Investment Bank.
The Sunday Times reported that the Green Investment Bank Commission will recommend that existing green business bodies such as the Carbon Trust, the Technology Strategy Board and the Marine Renewables Deployment Fund be pooled together to provide the bulk of the expertise and funding for the new bank.
The previous government had proposed selling off assets such as the student loan book and the Tote to raise the £2bn to fund the new bank, but with chancellor George Osborne keen to use revenue raised through asset sales to help tackle the deficit, the coalition is instead considering reallocating the funds already designated for environmental quangos.
Wigley is expected to argue that the £2bn spent each year on environmental support bodies could prove more effective if pooled within a green bank that will also be able to attract private finance.
The report is also expected to set out proposals for 'green bonds' that would allow private firms and individuals to invest in the new bank and will recommend that existing green grants are replaced by low-interest loans that allow the government to reinvest the same money several times over.
A spokeswoman for the Department of Energy and Climate Change told BusinessGreen.com that no decision had yet been made on the future of the Carbon Trust or other green quangos.
"Bob Wigley's independent report has not yet been published and no decisions have been taken about the scope and structure of the Green Investment Bank," she said. "The government is determined to address barriers to investment in the low-carbon economy and, as the chancellor said in the Budget, detailed proposals will be put forward following the spending review. The government is considering a wide range of options for the scope and structure of the bank."
Carbon Trust chief executive Tom Delay today attempted to downplay the chances of the organisation being scrapped and suggested the Wigley report would highlight successes at the agency.
"As many of our ideas for intervention have been included and our current innovation and business support activities are highlighted as successes in the report, we will work with the coalition government over the coming months as the report's options for implementation are carefully considered," he said.
However, Conservative ministers are known to be sceptical about the effectiveness of the Carbon Trust and Barker hinted strongly to The Sunday Times that consolidation of many of the government's existing green initiatives is in the pipeline. "There are a number of schemes, initiatives and quangos out there that in themselves do a good job, but the overall landscape is extremely cluttered and confused," he said.
LATEST STORIES ABOUT POLITICS
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
LATEST JOBS
TODAY'S TOP STORIES
HIGHLIGHT
The best green companies in the UK should be preparing their entries for annual BusinessGreen Leaders Awards
INSIGHT
INSIGHT
The science and practical application of an improved method for the specification of power and cooling infrastructure for data centres
A look at alternative approaches to managing energy for cost and/or sustainability reasons in data centres
WHAT DO YOU THINK? Add your comment
The Carbon Trust is and has led the way
Dear All, I accept I have a vested interest in this agenda but surely we have all learnt about the implications of relying on a bank. UK PLC needs best practice, long and short term sustainable investment programmes with proven yields provided by accreddited accountable professionals. Of the existing government vehicles distributing skills and funds with best practices that are already in place the Carbon Trust is the one to follow as they are directly engaged with customers, clients and practitioners across the UK in an open and accountable way. The Carbon Trust have strict vetting and control procedures that include the very best data sets in the UK obtained from real projects with clients that can verify the investment and business case. My organisation is fully independant non political and rigorous and tenacious about only providing workable economically viable energy solutions. To my knowledge there are around 500 other similar acreddited organisations based in the UK delivering the Carbon Trust products. All of the work is peer reviewed by the Atomic Energy Authority with the sole purpose of ensuring UK PLC is able to meet its energy demands and construct new macro and micro generation projects without returning to the boom and bust or rush for technologies without strategy. Our vision like many others is also related to that of the Carbon Trust. Just because the new government advisors are not familiar with the methodologies is no reason to jeopardise nearly 10,000 blue chip and micro chip UK businesses saving 20% on their energy costs reducing their opex and preserving jobs at the same time. They the CT are established and proven for over ten years with excellent world leading export capabilities along with training the next generation in skill sets now firmly acknowledged as essential for the UK. The other organisations are no where near them. I note that a foot in the mouth for a newly elected certain person in his constituency is looming as Witney is the administration base for the Carbon Trust. I challenge any (the NAO, the advisors and others) to provide assurances that any alternative system would represent better value for money and strategic benefits and high accountable standards than are already provided. With reference to our records we (my organisation) have verified nearly 1% of the UK energy efficiency loans at 0% interest in the first 2 quarters of this year. Yields are between 6% and 16%, all the information has been provided to organisations at a miniscule cost all vetted, transparent and available for scrutiny. How are the alternatives to accomodate this? Come on UK the Carbon Trust saves UK PLC 4 times what they cost, they provide best practice training, they are accountable across the board, what bank can say that. Best Regards
Posted by Paul Johannsen, 30 Jun 2010