ESG considerations mount at fixed income asset managers, industry survey finds

James Phillips
clock • 4 min read

Annual survey of asset managers by Russell Investments points to increasing focus and concern over climate risk

Asset managers are increasingly feeling the pressure from institutional investors including pension funds to address ESG issues and provide greater transparency on their efforts to tackle the risks, according to Russell Investments

A 2020 annual ESG survey published last week by Russell Investments found that asset managers' focus had been particularly amplified on climate risk, although governance issues continued to dominate, and that both engagement activities and internally-produced quantitative data were growing.

In the survey of 400 managers, an increasing number said ESG factors could dominate investment decisions, particularly where security returns or risk were affected. The remaining 36 per cent said ESG factors never dominated investment decisions, a drop from 45 per cent last year.

The majority of managers were increasing their access to proprietary data sources, with information gathered by 77 per cent from direct engagement with companies, up from 72 per cent, and 71 per cent from company reports or regulatory filings, up from 66 per cent.

Direct engagement is the main source of ESG data

Across equities, fixed income, and private markets, the number of managers reporting that they primarily relied on internally-produced quantitative data but still used some external data had increased, while those relying solely on external data fell.

Russell Investments director of fixed income research Yoshie Phillips said managers were "continuously trying to build a stronger framework to capture ESG-related info".

Evolving engagement

Fixed income managers were increasingly focusing on ESG issues and leveraging their investments, Phillips noted. The survey found that 38 per cent reported their regular meetings with management always included ESG discussions, up from 24 per cent last year. Meanwhile the number that never engaged with companies at all halved to 6 per cent.

"Engagement activities have evolved across asset classes. It has been a hot topic for fixed income managers," Phillips said. "The fixed income market accounts for $70tr market cap and most bond issuers do have to come back to the capital market, which means they have to keep a good face with the community.

"There is growing evidence that engagement can provide nudges, even by bondholders. If engagement doesn't result in desirable outcomes, that information itself is useful to asset managers when assessing activities but it is also important feedback for bondholders."

Data coverage for all fixed income segments was improving, the survey found, with both investment-grade and high-yield corporate bonds coming out top for data availability. However, both developed and emerging market sovereign bond data was below 50 per cent coverage, a figure that Phillips blamed on a lack of consistent reporting.

Across equity managers, 57 per cent said they voted against management proposals on at least one occasion, up ten percentage points on last year's survey. Meanwhile, 61 per cent of those based in the UK reported voting against between 0 and 10 per cent of management proposals in 2019, while 8 per cent said they voted against between 50 per cent and 100 per cent.

European equity managers voted against management most often

In the UK at least, the increased focus was largely put down to recent regulatory developments, including new requirements on trustees to provide implementation statements to set out how they have responded to financially material ESG risk.

Pervasive governance

Director of strategic client solutions and EMEA head of responsible investing Jihan Diolosa commented: "There are increasing numbers of questions around who we are engaging with, what are the managers' stories, and these are coming through from our existing clients and prospective clients. They are wanting more transparency in this space."

The governance element of ESG investing racked up the most focus, with 82 per cent of managers surveyed noting this was their primary concern, although the proportion selecting the environment has risen from 5 per cent to 13 per cent over the last two years.

Russell Investments said the uptick in the latter was largely due to the rise in local regulations, a pattern visible when looking at those who chose environmental considerations as the most important. The number within the UK selecting this in 2020 was 11 per cent, compared to seven per cent in 2018; for continental Europe the difference was more staggering, rising to 24 per cent from four per cent.

Phillips noted that the significance of governance might appear surprising when much of the ESG debate seems focused on climate risk - but she added that governance issues were more pervasive.

"Environment might be important for energy and electricity, but less important for banking," she said. "Corporate governance applies to companies regardless of industries. It is crucial to the company's long-term enterprise value."

Diolosa added: "Even though E, S and G are quite distinct, they are so closely interlinked. Just because G is dominating, it doesn't imply E and S are less important."


This article first appeared at BusinessGreen's sister site Professional Pensions

More on Investment

Credit: World Economic Forum/Ciaran McCrickard

GFANZ launches consultation to refine definitions of transition finance

Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero launches consultation to create 'consistent' definitions that would guide financial institutions' decarbonisation efforts

James Baxter-Derrington
clock 21 September 2023 • 2 min read
Credit: Scottish Leather Group

Scottish Leather Group: Low carbon leather supplier opens £14m 'super tannery'

Supplier to Aston Martin, Jaguar Land Rover, and British Airways cuts ribbon at multi-million-pound facility that aims to deliver net zero production by 2025

Stuart Stone
clock 19 September 2023 • 3 min read
Credit: Bute Energy

Wales Pension Partnership to plough £68m into Bute Energy's onshore wind plans

Renewable energy developer secures public sector investment for its vision to develop fleet of onshore wind farms in Wales

Holly Roach
clock 15 September 2023 • 2 min read