Lenovo has jumped to the number-one spot in Greenpeace International’s influential, if controversial, rankings for environmentally-friendly technology companies.
The Chinese giant displaced Nokia in the third and latest Green Electronics Guide studying the policies and activities of 14 leading technology companies. The new rankings mark a sharp improvement by Lenovo over the first Greenpeace poll of August 2006, where the firm ranked last of the vendors studied.
Lenovo ascribed it success to recent actions such as a free recycling programme and the phasing out of brominated flame retardants and PVC in products.
Greenpeace campaign co-ordinator Zeina al-Hajj said Lenovo’s rapid rise is “a big surprise. Lenovo has made a massive improvement”. She added that the firm’s “transparency” of access to information was particularly praiseworthy.
Nokia was second in Greenpeace’s listing, followed by Sony Ericsson, Dell and Samsung. However, Apple was once again bottom of the pile and Sony and LG were criticised by al-Hajj for “double standards”.
“We discovered that in the US they believe it’s not their responsibility but the consumers to collect equipment,” she added.
The survey, together with Greenpeace’s continued criticism of Apple, is likely to rankle with some observers who note that the Green Electronics Guide does not match up with another ranking scheme called the Electronic Product Environmental Assessment Tool (EPEAT). EPEAT is backed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
“EPEAT uses totally different criteria,” said al-Hajj. “They’re focused on the product and we’re focused on the policy. We believe they’re not as stringent and challenging to the industry as we are. Our purpose is to move the industry from abiding by law to driving change, and Apple is not taking leadership in design.”
Al-Hajj said the next challenge for technology vendors will be to move away from a strategy of “planned obsolescence” in product planning.
Super power efficient products can 'halve power usage' 15 Mar 2007Chipmaker cuts use of ozone-depleting halogen 07 Mar 2007
Charity wants Sony, Nintendo and Microsoft to clean up their act 20 May 2008
MacBook Air secures Greenpeace praise over improved energy efficiency and reduction in hazardous components 16 Jan 2008
Tests undertaken by environmental lobby group finds iPhone contains hazardous substances already eradicated by some rival phone manufacturers 15 Oct 2007Company responds to Greenpeace criticism with statement insisting iPhone meets all legal standards on hazardous substances 16 Oct 2007
Smartphone still using PVC and BFRs, claims environment group 16 Oct 2007
Report claiming solar panels take over 100 years to recoup their value is just plain wrong, say manufacturers 05 Sep 2008
New hybrid hatchback designed to make dual-drive vehicles more affordable 05 Sep 2008
Republican attempts to highlight differences over energy policy as both candidates pledge to deliver US energy independence 05 Sep 2008
More news
Once your company has gathered up all the low-hanging fruit, what comes next? Sarah Fister Gale finds that the answer lies in everything from multi-million dollar energy efficiency programmes to printers powered by exercise bikes 03 Sep 2008
Slow journey times mean airships are highly unlikely to replace passenger jets, but, as Danny Bradbury discovers, a flotilla of new companies are convinced that low-fuel costs mean the old-fashioned aircraft could have huge appeal to freight operators 02 Sep 2008
Recent claims from the oil giant's chief executive suggesting tar sand extraction is required to slow the shift to coal may have caught the eye, but as BusinessGreen.com discovers they do not make much sense 28 Aug 2008 More in-depth
Post your comment
Send an email to the Business Green editor at feedback@businessgreen.com
