The government’s failure to take on board the recommendations of independent reports on the national identity card scheme may lead to faults and extra cost, warn experts.
Last week, home secretary Jacqui Smith announced plans for a slower rollout of the £5.4bn ID cards programme, with the government retaining control of the national identity register.
But in a Treasury-commissioned report, also released last week, former HBOS chief executive Sir James Crosby recommends a fundamentally different, consumer-led approach.
“Our identity belongs to us, no one else,” said Crosby.
“The potential of any mass ID system such as ID cards lies in the extent to which it is created, by consumers for consumers.”
There are many reasons why the government may have ignored the Crosby report which has been delayed by almost a year and was released through the Treasury web site said Eric Woods, analyst at Ovum.
“Crosby’s recommendations on reaching a critical mass of card users quickly were always going to be unlikely due to the political and technical realities of the scheme,” he said.
Smith has delayed compulsory adoption of ID cards when renewing passports amid widespread criticism of the plan.
Crosby’s other recommendations which were ignored by the government include:
- ID cards should be free.
- The scheme should be subject to review by the information commissioner.
- Information should not be passed on to the police from the national identity register.
The government denies any Whitehall disagreement over ID cards. “The home secretary has talked to Sir James Crosby on each point of his report there is no disagreement between the Home Office and the Treasury over the scheme,” said a home office spokesman.
The government previously ignored the recommendations of a London School of Economics (LSE) report in 2005, which said the scheme could cost £19.2bn, said Ian Angell, professor of information systems at LSE.
“The government only listens to what it wants to hear current proposals are technically unsound and do not have public confidence,” he said.
Identity card rollout recommendations are ignored by the government 13 Mar 2008
Identity and Passport Service chief reveals benefits of new approach 07 Mar 2008
Draft report of alternative plans for ID management was ready six months ago 07 Mar 2008
Government does not want to provide biometric enrolment services itself 06 Mar 2008
People renewing a passport after 2010 will no longer be obliged to receive an ID card 06 Mar 2008Draft report of alternative plans for ID management was ready six months ago 07 Mar 2008Whitehall departments may not agree on the role of the IT infrastructure 23 Aug 2007
Treasury report will call for rapid take-up by citizens, say sources 09 Aug 2007CSC, EDS, Fujitsu, IBM, and Thales will all sign framework contracts 23 May 2008Government does not want to provide biometric enrolment services itself 06 Mar 2008
New legislative package to enable Bush's climate change fund pledge 18 Jul 2008
Iconic yellow taxi fleet to move to hybrids at a rate of 300 a month 18 Jul 2008
New outsourcing contract's sustainability criteria hoped to be used as template for future government IT deals 18 Jul 2008
More news
Every business seems to want a green label or quality mark, but with so many certification schemes now available which one should they choose? Tilde Herrera investigates 18 Jul 2008
Green motoring doesn't mean having to sacrifice style and speed - many premium makes combine fuel economy with carbon cutting features that help preserve the planet as well as your credibility 17 Jul 2008Having a green fleet is also the better value option 17 Jul 2008 More in-depth
Post your comment
Send an email to the Business Green editor at feedback@businessgreen.com
