Different parts of Whitehall have opposing views on the role of technology in establishing the identity card scheme, according to insiders.
The procurement, originally scheduled for October 2005, has only just begun, but the timetable for rolling out biometric identity cards to citizens remains largely unchanged.
Identity and Passport Service (IPS) chief executive James Hall said that cards will be issued gradually, giving both the technology and the physical processes time to settle in.
‘The intention is to start with small volumes but then scale up during 2010,’ said Hall.
However, the IPS plans are expected to be contradicted by a report by former HBOS chief executive Sir James Crosby on potential private sector involvement in the scheme. The report, commissioned by Gordon Brown, will be published later this year, and according to sources, Crosby will recommend that the scheme reaches a critical mass of citizens as soon as possible (Computing, 9 August).
But Hall warns that faster rollout will place an unnecessary strain on both budgetary planning and the physical enrolment infrastructure.
‘I agree with the point of view that if it is a worthwhile scheme then it is beneficial to implement it sooner rather than later,’ said Hall.
‘But the challenge is that if we enrol more people in a given year we need a bigger infrastructure to do it.
‘And it becomes important to find ways of driving down costs so we avoid a massive cost in a short period of time.’
Insiders say the different timescales point to a fundamental divergence between the IPS and Crosby’s Treasury team.
The IPS view is of a scheme defined by the technology implementation. But Crosby thinks that the cards can be rolled out quickly, relying on facial identification from photographs rather than having a full biometric technology infrastructure.
‘IPS hopes to proceed on the basis of a gold standard where-as Crosby is arguing for a silver standard that is, drop in the technology incrementally but get cards out fast,’ said a source close to the programme.
‘It would be a way to get the scheme going without the full technology infrastructure.’
Treasury report will call for rapid take-up by citizens, say sources 09 Aug 2007
Electronic security scheme cost estimates soar in past two years 09 Aug 2007
Frustration builds as technology procurement still has not begun 26 Jul 2007
Timetable schedules first contract awards for second quarter of 2008 24 May 2007
Crosby report to benefit from 'clear air' of new PM, say sources 12 Apr 2007
Government does not want to provide biometric enrolment services itself 06 Mar 2008
Identity and Passport Service chief reveals benefits of new approach 07 Mar 2008Home Office slows ID card rollout as independent Treasury study recommends fast implementation 13 Mar 2008
Draft report of alternative plans for ID management was ready six months ago 07 Mar 2008
Report claiming solar panels take over 100 years to recoup their value is just plain wrong, say manufacturers 05 Sep 2008
New hybrid hatchback designed to make dual-drive vehicles more affordable 05 Sep 2008
Republican attempts to highlight differences over energy policy as both candidates pledge to deliver US energy independence 05 Sep 2008
More news
Once your company has gathered up all the low-hanging fruit, what comes next? Sarah Fister Gale finds that the answer lies in everything from multi-million dollar energy efficiency programmes to printers powered by exercise bikes 03 Sep 2008
Slow journey times mean airships are highly unlikely to replace passenger jets, but, as Danny Bradbury discovers, a flotilla of new companies are convinced that low-fuel costs mean the old-fashioned aircraft could have huge appeal to freight operators 02 Sep 2008
Recent claims from the oil giant's chief executive suggesting tar sand extraction is required to slow the shift to coal may have caught the eye, but as BusinessGreen.com discovers they do not make much sense 28 Aug 2008 More in-depth
Post your comment
Send an email to the Business Green editor at feedback@businessgreen.com
